The U.S. health care system's informal “Third Net” of fragmented, alternative clinics provides essential care to undocumented, low-income, and uninsured migrants while simultaneously exposing the structural inequities and systemic limitations of the formal health care system.
WEBVTT
1
00:00:00.000 --> 00:00:05.739
CSIM Presenter: to date… To the last presentation.
2
00:00:06.280 --> 00:00:12.449
CSIM Presenter: This quarter of the… Of the Center for the Study of International Migration.
3
00:00:12.550 --> 00:00:22.079
CSIM Presenter: This presentation is co-sponsored by the other three UC research centers. The…
4
00:00:22.530 --> 00:00:34.479
CSIM Presenter: The Center for Comparative Immigration Studies at UC San Diego, Berkeley Interdisciplinary Migration Initiative, and UC Davis' Global Migration Center. So we will have
5
00:00:34.630 --> 00:00:38.590
CSIM Presenter: people joining us from across the UC.
6
00:00:39.280 --> 00:00:58.100
CSIM Presenter: And, so today we are well… we're very happy to welcome Lisa Park, professor, she's a sociologist and professor of Asian American Studies at UC Santa Barbara. It's a very UC event today, it just so happened.
7
00:00:58.180 --> 00:01:07.069
CSIM Presenter: And our discussion is our very own, Professor Randall Kuhn from the Fielding School of Public Health.
8
00:01:07.500 --> 00:01:13.080
CSIM Presenter: A very, very brief introduction here,
9
00:01:13.880 --> 00:01:16.919
CSIM Presenter: Let's see, where is my…
10
00:01:17.020 --> 00:01:27.930
CSIM Presenter: Okay. Professor Park, Park's interdisciplinary research focuses on the politics of migration, race, and social policy.
11
00:01:28.000 --> 00:01:47.180
CSIM Presenter: Her most recent books include Entitled to Nothing, The Struggle for Immigrant Healthcare in the Age of Welfare Reform, published in 2011, and The Slums of Aspen, Immigrants vs. the Environment in America's Eden, co-authored with David Pello, published also in 2011.
12
00:01:47.870 --> 00:02:01.550
CSIM Presenter: of particular focus of research is the patchwork of healthcare negotiated by low-income undocumented immigrants in need of long-term care within the U.S.-Mexico border states.
13
00:02:01.670 --> 00:02:08.640
CSIM Presenter: In addition to the book that, that Lisa is going to present today, co-authored with
14
00:02:08.789 --> 00:02:15.450
CSIM Presenter: Erin, Hofstra and Anthony Jimenez.
15
00:02:15.570 --> 00:02:26.960
CSIM Presenter: She's working on a second project on the unionization efforts of home care workers in Minnesota, which extends her research interest in gendered labor within the global economy.
16
00:02:27.600 --> 00:02:44.639
CSIM Presenter: Professor Randall Kuhn is a demographer and sociologist focused on the social determinants of health among vulnerable populations. He leads a 35-year longitudinal study on the impact of health and development programs in Bangladesh.
17
00:02:45.100 --> 00:03:02.299
CSIM Presenter: But in his other area on homelessness, Randall has conducted some of the earliest… conducted some of the earliest quantitative research on health and substance use risk among chronically homeless adults. He currently leads the periodic assessment of trajectories of housing.
18
00:03:02.510 --> 00:03:17.280
CSIM Presenter: major survey, assessment of trajectories of housing, homelessness, and health survey of Los Angeles counties and house population. So, I'm very happy to welcome
19
00:03:17.390 --> 00:03:23.299
CSIM Presenter: all of you to this conversation that we're going to have today.
20
00:03:23.370 --> 00:03:37.959
CSIM Presenter: Professor Park is going to speak for about 30-35 minutes. Professor Kuhn is going to follow with about 10-15 minutes of commentary, and then we're going to open it up for questions at the end. So, thank you, and welcome, Lisa.
21
00:03:42.800 --> 00:03:53.800
CSIM Presenter: Good afternoon. Thank you so much for this opportunity to be here with you all today, here in person and online. I wanted to first,
22
00:03:53.800 --> 00:04:09.340
CSIM Presenter: you know, offer my sincere gratitude to Professor Menuvar and to Kim McNally, as well as the other organizers of the UC Migrant Center's Book Talk series, and of course, along with Professor Randall Kuhn, for this opportunity to speak with you.
23
00:04:09.380 --> 00:04:14.860
CSIM Presenter: I thought I would begin today with, the introductory vignette that's actually on page 1.
24
00:04:15.620 --> 00:04:16.779
CSIM Presenter: So it begins.
25
00:04:16.930 --> 00:04:32.290
CSIM Presenter: Like most clinics of its kind, it has no distinguishing marks to signal its internal workings. The small, nondescript, rectangular, single-story building is covered in varying shades of brown and beige paint after so many years of neglect.
26
00:04:32.310 --> 00:04:40.440
CSIM Presenter: There are no signs to indicate that this is a medical facility that fulfills a crucial role in the overall healthcare system.
27
00:04:40.510 --> 00:04:49.489
CSIM Presenter: The entry… the entry doorway opens to two waiting rooms. On the left, people are quietly sitting, and on the right, volunteer nurses.
28
00:04:49.630 --> 00:04:58.890
CSIM Presenter: Doctors and medical students are briskly walking in and out of a series of small examination rooms that snake all the way to the back door.
29
00:05:00.130 --> 00:05:13.009
CSIM Presenter: A handwritten sign on the wall reads, quote, We only and exclusively give care to undocumented people, end quote. The clinic opens at 6 or 6.30 a.m. most mornings, and there's always a line.
30
00:05:13.060 --> 00:05:24.319
CSIM Presenter: There are no appointments, people must arrive early and wait, and even then, there is no guarantee that they will be seen by the two doctors, both formerly retired from their profession years ago.
31
00:05:24.620 --> 00:05:27.399
CSIM Presenter: The wait for the dentist is even longer.
32
00:05:28.240 --> 00:05:34.530
CSIM Presenter: Since she only visits once or twice a month, and there is a raffle system to decide who will get to see her today.
33
00:05:34.750 --> 00:05:46.499
CSIM Presenter: A friendly woman with an easy smile, the dentist admits that all she can really do at the clinic is pull teeth. But that does not stop the local hospital from referring uninsured migrant patients to her.
34
00:05:46.600 --> 00:06:00.170
CSIM Presenter: In the next room is an endocrinologist who focuses almost exclusively on diabetic patients. A migrant from South America, he has been retired for years, but continues to volunteer at the clinic two days a week.
35
00:06:00.410 --> 00:06:08.700
CSIM Presenter: This is what healthcare looks like for undocumented migrants in the United States, if you are lucky. This is the third net.
36
00:06:09.140 --> 00:06:14.549
CSIM Presenter: So I'd like to, talk a little bit more about what it is that we saw.
37
00:06:15.460 --> 00:06:17.690
CSIM Presenter: Wait, hold on, sorry.
38
00:06:18.780 --> 00:06:19.899
CSIM Presenter: Here he is.
39
00:06:20.730 --> 00:06:33.850
CSIM Presenter: So, underneath the formal safety net system of healthcare is an informal, threadbare, and disconnected assortment of organizations that provide basic care to millions of migrants across the United States.
40
00:06:33.850 --> 00:06:42.139
CSIM Presenter: They have wildly varying levels of service, organizational culture, and mission. It's a patchwork of free, or mostly free.
41
00:06:42.140 --> 00:06:45.410
CSIM Presenter: Healthcare for those excluded from the formal health system.
42
00:06:46.190 --> 00:07:01.149
CSIM Presenter: What we tried to do with our study is to document the existence of this informal and sometimes underground infrastructure to provide a glimpse into these spaces and what they tell us about the vulnerabilities of the overall structure of healthcare in the United States.
43
00:07:01.180 --> 00:07:09.419
CSIM Presenter: More specifically, we were particularly interested in the healthcare safety net for undocumented, low-income, and uninsured migrants in the U.S.
44
00:07:09.490 --> 00:07:26.410
CSIM Presenter: We approach this jumble of safety net healthcare providers as an infrastructure that is hierarchically organized in distinct but interactive levels, or nets. In this way, we outline the logic that orders this purposive disarray of care.
45
00:07:26.460 --> 00:07:36.119
CSIM Presenter: Our multi-sided and multi-methodological study found that the informal thirdNet buttressed the formal system by serving as basically a dumping ground.
46
00:07:36.430 --> 00:07:56.099
CSIM Presenter: There is no exact definition of what constitutes infrastructure. What makes something or somewhat essential to modern state governance could vary, particularly given that it is relational and ecological. Meaning, a technology might be viewed as necessary for the governance of one particular context or environment, but not necessarily another.
47
00:07:56.200 --> 00:08:11.330
CSIM Presenter: The infrastructure of the ThirdNet is comprised of an informal cadre of volunteers with a wide range of tools, resources, and experiences who provide basic care in ways that reflect the political and social conditions of their region.
48
00:08:11.490 --> 00:08:23.190
CSIM Presenter: The state of the U.S. healthcare system and its fraying safety net is a hierarchical process that shifts with the people, politics, and larger social context… sorry, context.
49
00:08:23.680 --> 00:08:38.220
CSIM Presenter: At the same time, there is an order and purpose to this collection of seemingly disarray of parts. Our study shows that the informal third net of the healthcare safety net functions as a facet of modern poverty governance.
50
00:08:38.590 --> 00:08:50.269
CSIM Presenter: And as social scientists have convincingly argued before, the goal of poverty governance is not to actually eliminate poverty, but rather manage the poor into docile and industrious subjects.
51
00:08:50.370 --> 00:09:06.310
CSIM Presenter: The overall healthcare infrastructure, including practitioners in the third net, play a critical role in regulating the everyday lives of people in poverty. The invaluable condition of health, along with the elevated social status and moral authority.
52
00:09:06.390 --> 00:09:18.780
CSIM Presenter: attributed to healthcare providers allow for extraordinary disciplinary powers. At the same time, there are variations in the use of this power across the tiers of the healthcare infrastructure. Within the third net.
53
00:09:19.010 --> 00:09:26.489
CSIM Presenter: Healthcare safety net practitioners function as street-level bureaucrats, who play a unique role in poverty governance.
54
00:09:26.720 --> 00:09:44.740
CSIM Presenter: So rather than a Weberian vision of bureaucracy as some sort of a strict system of super and subordination, where straight-level bureaucrats execute the state's demands, healthcare providers in the third net are frontline workers who bridge gaps in the healthcare infrastructure.
55
00:09:44.810 --> 00:09:57.360
CSIM Presenter: These street-level bureaucrats leverage their networks and relationships to facilitate access to resources, and in this way, they're influenced, but not entirely beholden to the state's authority.
56
00:10:00.050 --> 00:10:09.649
CSIM Presenter: So, at the same time, their extreme marginality as part of the larger healthcare infrastructure also serves as a challenge to the system itself.
57
00:10:09.670 --> 00:10:20.870
CSIM Presenter: Through their labor, they have the capacity to negotiate a middle ground between the demands of the state from above and needs of people from below, but with their own set of motivations.
58
00:10:21.280 --> 00:10:30.960
CSIM Presenter: Now, a few words about how we approached this project. We began the study soon after the passage of the Affordable Care Act in 2014.
59
00:10:31.540 --> 00:10:47.119
CSIM Presenter: what we had initially thought was we wanted to go out there and see what was happening to undocumented immigrants, if anything. And this was an interesting question because, and certainly as sociologists, right, we were very interested, in part because policy-wise, there should not have been any significant change.
60
00:10:47.120 --> 00:10:55.990
CSIM Presenter: Given that most undocumented migrants were restricted from public health insurance prior to ACA, so when ACA passes, it should be the same, right?
61
00:10:55.990 --> 00:10:58.569
CSIM Presenter: But in fact, we found something else.
62
00:10:59.010 --> 00:11:10.909
CSIM Presenter: You might also recall that, that the explicit exclusion of undocumented migrants from the ACA was part of what was key in allowing for its passage.
63
00:11:10.910 --> 00:11:20.910
CSIM Presenter: In this way, the exclusion of undocumented migrants was directly tied to the expansion of Medicaid to millions of low-income citizens.
64
00:11:21.640 --> 00:11:43.990
CSIM Presenter: So we first identified safety net hospitals and clinics, as well as migrant health advocates in cities along the four states that border Mexico. So we started first in Houston, Texas, then we went into Albuquerque, New Mexico, then met with folks in Phoenix and Tucson, Arizona, as well as then ended up in San Diego, California. So it's literally a drive-through across the southern states.
65
00:11:44.500 --> 00:11:46.300
CSIM Presenter: Or southwestern states.
66
00:11:46.460 --> 00:12:02.399
CSIM Presenter: We visited each site, conducting in-person interviews with key respondents. We returned again two years later, in 2016, to document the implementation process and to see how things have changed over time, because as any of us know who work in policy knows.
67
00:12:02.490 --> 00:12:12.219
CSIM Presenter: policy has its own sort of way of, moving, right? And it… what we thought, right, doesn't always turn out to be what it will be.
68
00:12:12.380 --> 00:12:26.990
CSIM Presenter: So we went back. And as our study progressed, our interests broadened beyond the ACA as we began to see the outlines of an infrastructure within a very messy, informal landscape of the safety net system.
69
00:12:27.290 --> 00:12:48.379
CSIM Presenter: We then initiated in-depth ethnographies at particular ThirdNet organizations in two different states, right? So we went back a third time, right? But this time it was for a year-long ethnography in two different locations, so that we were able to get sort of rich description, right, of the infrastructure from the vantage point of those within it, right?
70
00:12:48.620 --> 00:12:59.570
CSIM Presenter: I should also make a note here that, you know, I started off thinking that this was my solo project, but with two spectacular graduate students with me,
71
00:12:59.570 --> 00:13:14.040
CSIM Presenter: Aaron Hoekstra and Anthony Jimenez, we… I quickly realized that this is, you know, three minds definitely work better than one. And, we took it on as our collective project, which is how we came up with this co-authored book, right?
72
00:13:14.950 --> 00:13:27.409
CSIM Presenter: Alright, so the ThirdNet. I wanted to take a minute now, or a few minutes, to talk about, some… the varieties, right, within the 3rdNet organizations that we saw.
73
00:13:27.680 --> 00:13:31.209
CSIM Presenter: I'm sorry if you can't see it too well, it's a little bit…
74
00:13:31.720 --> 00:13:37.189
CSIM Presenter: maybe I should have chosen a different color scheme, but in any case, basically what we saw,
75
00:13:37.330 --> 00:14:00.709
CSIM Presenter: And I should say that this isn't the, sort of, the, the only categories. There may be quite a greater, much greater variations in the different kinds of philosophies of care, but we thought this… we could show some of the variation, right, with this sample that we had. So we, saw three philosophies of care.
76
00:14:00.710 --> 00:14:03.520
CSIM Presenter: Right? Which is traditional charity care.
77
00:14:03.520 --> 00:14:15.770
CSIM Presenter: We saw what we called the social justice philosophy of care, as well as mutual aid philosophy of care. And I thought I might sort of introduce you a bit to what we saw, and how they differed a bit from each other.
78
00:14:15.770 --> 00:14:32.689
CSIM Presenter: So, the traditional charity care. These are free clinics and charities that are often more publicly visible and generally well known in comparison to other organizations in the ThirdNet. As such, they're often, though not always, more established, they're larger, and they're better resourced and connected.
79
00:14:32.760 --> 00:14:44.909
CSIM Presenter: These organizations may be the recipients of government and large foundation funding, and focus our work almost exclusively on the immediate healthcare and service provision for uninsured or underinsured patients.
80
00:14:44.930 --> 00:14:56.100
CSIM Presenter: Often, this service provision includes patient screenings, they do primary care, they provide low-cost or even free prescription medicines, and as well as health education.
81
00:14:56.810 --> 00:15:13.880
CSIM Presenter: So one example would be Grace in Action, right? This is a church-based mobile clinic on wheels that moves from one church parking lot to another. And I should say the mobile clinic, this is a massive RV, right? And it's been retrofitted to look like,
82
00:15:13.880 --> 00:15:16.989
CSIM Presenter: And to function as a doctor's office, right?
83
00:15:17.030 --> 00:15:21.969
CSIM Presenter: They provide regular tours for interested visitors to show their good work.
84
00:15:21.970 --> 00:15:42.210
CSIM Presenter: As well as solicit donations. They've been in operation for over 25 years now, and Grace is the largest and most well-resourced of all the organizations in our study. They served, over 3,000 patients across the Phoenix metro area. They also provide free prescriptions for over 225 generic medications.
85
00:15:42.830 --> 00:15:59.480
CSIM Presenter: The second category is social justice, and this involves both a discourse and a practice in which the organizations approach their mission from a rights-based perspective. So, a considerable portion of these kinds of organizations, nonprofits, and clinic spaces
86
00:16:00.200 --> 00:16:05.370
CSIM Presenter: They adhere to this kind of philosophy and view their work as not only providing healthcare.
87
00:16:05.440 --> 00:16:24.099
CSIM Presenter: to meet immediate needs of their patients, but they also see their mission as dismantling the larger structural issues, giving rise to health disparities, giving… which is why we named the term justice, right? So, for instance, one organization that we work with is what we call CCP.
88
00:16:24.320 --> 00:16:42.999
CSIM Presenter: CCP is located in a nondescript little house, which had been abandoned for years. It was then refurbished by volunteers into a makeshift, unlicensed clinic run by health activists. There's literally no sign, right? You would never know that this is a clinic at all, right?
89
00:16:43.000 --> 00:16:51.630
CSIM Presenter: Before CCP came along, this house was well known as a neighborhood source for procuring illicit drugs, aka it was a crack house.
90
00:16:51.680 --> 00:16:56.270
CSIM Presenter: Anyway, the house was sold by the city, and I think it was just for, like, a dollar, right?
91
00:16:56.270 --> 00:17:14.329
CSIM Presenter: I don't know, it was something very cheap, right? So, the house was sold by the city with the expectation that the buyer would tear it down and develop a large lot. Instead, CCP volunteers Ed and Donna bought it, they gutted the building, and remodeled it into a house that could also be used as a clinic.
92
00:17:14.910 --> 00:17:26.410
CSIM Presenter: Michael, one of CCP's main nursing volunteers, reminisced, before we had the clinic, we were just doing house calls and seeing patients out of the kitchen at the local Migrant Rights Center.
93
00:17:26.410 --> 00:17:36.779
CSIM Presenter: He motioned around him, right, to this tiny kitchen where I was interviewing him, which I turned into a volunteer office when it had floor-to-ceiling shelves of medical supplies.
94
00:17:36.780 --> 00:17:44.059
CSIM Presenter: And he said, quote, It's cramped quarters here for sure, but it's drastically increased our capacity to see patients.
95
00:17:44.060 --> 00:17:48.870
CSIM Presenter: Ed likes to joke that it's just a different kind of drug house now, end quote.
96
00:17:49.040 --> 00:18:06.629
CSIM Presenter: The clinic relies on hundreds of volunteers to provide a variety of primary and specialist care, to fundraise, to clean the clinic, they restock the medical supplies, and generally keep the organization running. I should note that this organization also limits the number of patients that they will see.
97
00:18:06.630 --> 00:18:14.909
CSIM Presenter: So there's a huge waiting line, but the waiting list… but the reason why they do this is so that they can actually provide more specialist care, which is a rare thing.
98
00:18:16.190 --> 00:18:27.119
CSIM Presenter: The, the volunteers for CCP are an interesting mix of people. They include members of a street medic collective that provides healthcare at migrant rights protests.
99
00:18:27.210 --> 00:18:38.349
CSIM Presenter: And this is particularly important at the time that we were interviewing them, because this is during, the reign of Sheriff Arpaio, and the kinds of,
100
00:18:38.550 --> 00:18:42.390
CSIM Presenter: Intense hostilities that was going on at the time.
101
00:18:42.390 --> 00:19:04.729
CSIM Presenter: In addition, there were also doctors, nurses, and physician's assistants who were working in local hospitals and medical offices, who were then providing their volunteer time during their off hours, or coming into this small clinic. And then we also saw, curanderas and other spiritual leaders who are themselves migrants, who are also providing services.
102
00:19:04.730 --> 00:19:19.030
CSIM Presenter: And then there was also a regular, rotating group of young, affluent, white, suburbanites who were aspiring medical students who were looking for a quote-unquote, or looking for experience with, quote-unquote, underserved populations.
103
00:19:19.230 --> 00:19:20.440
CSIM Presenter: It helped there.
104
00:19:20.630 --> 00:19:28.740
CSIM Presenter: application for med school. Anyway, so on to the third category, right? This is the category of care that we call mutual aid.
105
00:19:29.610 --> 00:19:48.320
CSIM Presenter: This is a cooperative framework, right, based on the reciprocal exchange of goods, services, or skills, ideas, and other resources, often between members of the same community or individuals in similar social groups. So mutual aid is premised on the idea that everyone has something they can contribute, and everyone has something that they need.
106
00:19:48.490 --> 00:20:00.199
CSIM Presenter: In many ways, mutual aid is a framework of community solidarity, which stands in opposition to traditional forms of charity, and even against the prevailing hierarchies of social justice organizations.
107
00:20:00.530 --> 00:20:19.729
CSIM Presenter: For instance, I'm going to take a couple of minutes to talk about Houston Health Action. And this is a grassroots, community-based, migrant-led organization of uninsured, undocumented migrants with disabilities, the majority of whom have experienced, injuries, serious injuries, or amputations.
108
00:20:19.770 --> 00:20:21.849
CSIM Presenter: They've been around for 20 years.
109
00:20:21.950 --> 00:20:29.110
CSIM Presenter: Health Action has primarily served people with spinal cord injuries who use wheelchairs for mobility, and…
110
00:20:29.400 --> 00:20:46.010
CSIM Presenter: The number of folks who need this care is quite remarkable, particularly because, as we know, many immigrants work in some of the most dangerous jobs, and so many of these folks were injured on the job, or trying to get to or from their jobs, right?
111
00:20:47.280 --> 00:20:57.220
CSIM Presenter: The organization began when the county safety net health system stopped offering medical supplies and services to those ineligible for Medicaid.
112
00:20:57.320 --> 00:21:10.869
CSIM Presenter: These patients depend on a vital medical supplies, including sterile catheters, diapers, urine, drainage bags, and gloves, right? These are sort of basic kinds of medical supplies, nothing fancy, right?
113
00:21:10.940 --> 00:21:18.829
CSIM Presenter: But out of pocket, these supplies could cost at least $400 a month, and that was back 10 years ago when we were interviewing them.
114
00:21:18.890 --> 00:21:39.619
CSIM Presenter: which is prohibitively expensive for those who are not eligible for public benefits or uninsured and unemployed. They fundraise and pool their funds so that they may buy the necessary supplies in bulk, because of course that's much cheaper, right? And then they divide them among the organization's membership, and during monthly supply distributions.
115
00:21:40.070 --> 00:21:59.620
CSIM Presenter: And just as important, they foster hope and solidarity as an organization in order to improve the mental health and overall quality of life for their members. They work to combat isolation by building a support network where people with similar experiences and challenges can feel included, respected, and even loved.
116
00:21:59.900 --> 00:22:05.530
CSIM Presenter: The organization works to foster independence and an autonomy for its members.
117
00:22:05.630 --> 00:22:15.390
CSIM Presenter: And at the same time, create an intentional community that feels more like a chosen family. They share holiday celebrations, birthday shower… or birthday shower…
118
00:22:15.390 --> 00:22:33.610
CSIM Presenter: No, baby showers, birthday parties, and even funerals. Health Action members collectively support each other through the traumas that they have survived, and work to cultivate their relationships with each other. They also engage in advocacy efforts built on principles of disability rights, health justice, and migrant rights.
119
00:22:33.750 --> 00:22:44.390
CSIM Presenter: Their activism has included everything from stopping a fare increase for public transportation in Harris County, to lobbying against anti-immigration legislation at the state level.
120
00:22:44.520 --> 00:22:53.969
CSIM Presenter: In all its efforts, Health Action not only works to highlight the exclusion and exploitation of its members, but also their strength and ingenuity.
121
00:22:54.520 --> 00:22:56.699
CSIM Presenter: And across all these locales.
122
00:22:56.900 --> 00:23:06.840
CSIM Presenter: These five organizations provide a representation of the various types of ThirdNet organizing with varying and sometimes overlapping missions, visions, and approaches to healthcare.
123
00:23:06.900 --> 00:23:21.580
CSIM Presenter: They all face, of course, serious constraints that's posed by migrants' ineligibility for health insurance, and the real resource challenges of free healthcare provision within a larger, expensive, privatized healthcare system.
124
00:23:21.770 --> 00:23:39.280
CSIM Presenter: Not to mention the hostile, racist, and anti-immigrant politics that surrounds them. And as a result, these ThirdNet organizations are forced to cobble together an infrastructure of preventive, primary, holistic, and sometimes even specialist care from the expertise of their volunteers.
125
00:23:39.410 --> 00:23:43.280
CSIM Presenter: And the donated and often very outdated medical equipment.
126
00:23:43.340 --> 00:23:51.740
CSIM Presenter: At the same time, hospitals, healthcare providers, and social service agencies, and I should also note, immigration authorities like ICE,
127
00:23:51.740 --> 00:24:04.330
CSIM Presenter: Refer a steady stream of patients to these organizations, as they are many times the only option for healthcare for uninsured, undocumented migrants, aside from emergency care.
128
00:24:05.570 --> 00:24:21.079
CSIM Presenter: So, what did we find? So what… so as part of what we found… okay, I should say… so part of our findings, then, is that these seemingly disparate, disconnected, and wide-ranging clinics and organizations combine to form a base… the basis of a larger societal project.
129
00:24:21.100 --> 00:24:28.739
CSIM Presenter: As the dumping ground for the formal healthcare system, the self… the third net absorbs and helps mask.
130
00:24:28.770 --> 00:24:33.980
CSIM Presenter: The inefficiencies, the illogic, and the cruelty of modern poverty governance.
131
00:24:34.000 --> 00:24:51.200
CSIM Presenter: Our study shows how low-income migrants do not simply fall through the cracks of a broken healthcare system, but rather, the healthcare infrastructure is purposely created to externalize migrants to the third net. Let me show you a little bit more about what we mean by this.
132
00:24:58.690 --> 00:25:15.610
CSIM Presenter: So first, there's no single system of healthcare in the United States. Instead, it's a complex mix of private, public, for-profit, and non-profit insurers and healthcare providers, as well as we have pharmaceuticals, pharmacies in addition.
133
00:25:15.610 --> 00:25:27.689
CSIM Presenter: So, I find this particular, graph or figure from the Commonwealth Fund useful, right? And what I find particularly useful about this
134
00:25:27.690 --> 00:25:37.269
CSIM Presenter: graph is that, as you will see, the organization of our U.S. healthcare system is basically organized by money. It is by financing, right?
135
00:25:38.330 --> 00:25:42.850
CSIM Presenter: The third net is largely disconnected from this entire system.
136
00:25:42.850 --> 00:25:58.879
CSIM Presenter: Right? It is located in a parallel context. It's a fuzzy shadow, right? That extends past the existing arrows in the figure. A map of the third net might begin with the charity box, located in the far right-hand corner. It's that little itty-bitty thing.
137
00:25:58.950 --> 00:26:01.450
CSIM Presenter: at the far end, right?
138
00:26:04.570 --> 00:26:11.909
CSIM Presenter: And so if we were to map the third net, it would have to extend that arrow from the charity off this whole figure, right?
139
00:26:11.980 --> 00:26:27.000
CSIM Presenter: And without direct connect… because it has no direct connection to either, you know, public or private, sort of formal financing, the ThirdNet is largely invisible, and its chart, if you will, might look something like this.
140
00:26:28.560 --> 00:26:37.739
CSIM Presenter: It's a little ridiculous, right? However, our research delves into this neglected sector and maps a different, far more intricate system within a system.
141
00:26:37.750 --> 00:26:57.030
CSIM Presenter: Without formal funding sources, the ThirdNet has an infrastructure of its own, driven by a network of interpersonal relationships and formal funding sources, and informal funding sources. Organizations within the third net may not be relegated or regulated by the state, or even acknowledged as a healthcare entity at all.
142
00:26:57.030 --> 00:27:00.569
CSIM Presenter: By federal agencies, or governmental agencies.
143
00:27:01.880 --> 00:27:06.449
CSIM Presenter: So, what does the healthcare system look like from the vantage point of the third net?
144
00:27:07.600 --> 00:27:10.639
CSIM Presenter: We offer this inverted pyramid, right?
145
00:27:11.550 --> 00:27:19.319
CSIM Presenter: Where, if you look at the formal healthcare system, right, we have at the top, right, the,
146
00:27:19.470 --> 00:27:21.840
CSIM Presenter: Private healthcare sector, right?
147
00:27:22.150 --> 00:27:27.800
CSIM Presenter: And then we have the next, we have a healthcare safety net.
148
00:27:27.800 --> 00:27:43.100
CSIM Presenter: Right? Which includes the first and second nets, right, which are more formal, and they're publicly funded. And then we have, at the bottom, the third net, which is informal and, donation-based. And I should say, you know, we… this…
149
00:27:43.220 --> 00:28:02.270
CSIM Presenter: the sizes of these little, spaces, does not actually, coordinate to the actual amount of money, right? Because otherwise, ThirdNet would be a dot, right? It would not even exist. But for, you know, for our purposes, though, this is sort of the organization, right, as, as we saw it.
150
00:28:03.270 --> 00:28:22.279
CSIM Presenter: One of the interesting things, then, I also want to note here is that, while the third net is so disconnected in terms of finances, it is also… however, it is actually absolutely connected in terms of policy, right? Meaning, the policy changes that happen in the first and second nets, right? As well as the
151
00:28:22.280 --> 00:28:32.079
CSIM Presenter: you know, the private sector, right, reverberate to the third, right? And certainly, this is the case for the undocumented migrants after the passage of ACA.
152
00:28:32.200 --> 00:28:34.840
CSIM Presenter: Okay.
153
00:28:38.750 --> 00:28:51.629
CSIM Presenter: So, I wanted to talk a bit more, then, about the safety net sectors, right? First and second, right, net of the safety nets, which are the formal safety nets, and then, of course, the third net is the informal, right?
154
00:28:51.860 --> 00:28:59.379
CSIM Presenter: And here, we categorize the first net, right, of the formal safety net as… these are…
155
00:28:59.520 --> 00:29:18.639
CSIM Presenter: some of them, huge hospitals, right? Hospital, and entire hospital systems, right? Harris County, for instance, in Houston, is a massive healthcare safe net system, right? They not only have a huge teaching hospital, right, but they also, own all these, community clinics as well, right?
156
00:29:18.640 --> 00:29:42.070
CSIM Presenter: And they provide all kinds of care, including primary specialists, as well as emergency care. The second net, right, is also formal, and these are the community health clinics. They're also… we also include the federally qualified, health centers. They also… they provide primary and ad hoc specialist care, and, preventative, and they're funded largely, by
157
00:29:42.070 --> 00:29:43.659
CSIM Presenter: Government funds.
158
00:29:44.600 --> 00:30:00.820
CSIM Presenter: The ThirdNet is distinctive, again, in its informal organizational structure, lack of paid employees, and donation funding base. The number of organizations in the ThirdNet are not just non-profit or non… but also non-existent as a source of healthcare.
159
00:30:00.840 --> 00:30:13.950
CSIM Presenter: In every way, the third net appears misplaced and anachronistic as part of the system, and yet it is pivotal to the functioning of the overall infrastructure precisely because of its unique features. For instance, right.
160
00:30:14.130 --> 00:30:19.229
CSIM Presenter: In the, core first and second safety nets, right, of the hospitals and clinics.
161
00:30:19.400 --> 00:30:26.240
CSIM Presenter: They actually have limited and restricted revenue sources in comparison to private hospitals, right, that top layer.
162
00:30:26.400 --> 00:30:41.419
CSIM Presenter: And they also… these safety nets have complex governance and leadership structures that accompany public funds. Ironically, as a marginalized entity with little to no government funds, the third net operate unencumbered by these restrictions.
163
00:30:41.420 --> 00:31:05.379
CSIM Presenter: However, there are significant and obvious downsides, right, to relying on individual charity, the kinds of care provided, the number of patients that can be seen is certainly severely limited, and the infrastructural foundations are highly unstable in comparison to other formally recognized safety net organizations. Also, freedom from governmental restrictions does not mean that they do not have any
164
00:31:05.380 --> 00:31:06.320
CSIM Presenter: rules.
165
00:31:06.320 --> 00:31:17.269
CSIM Presenter: In fact, we show that organizations in the ThirdNet take great pains to develop their own guidelines and mission, as well as collectively contribute towards the functioning of the overall system.
166
00:31:17.310 --> 00:31:26.330
CSIM Presenter: In other words, The infrastructural instability of the informal performs an important function in the stability of the formal.
167
00:31:26.570 --> 00:31:34.140
CSIM Presenter: It is no coincidence that ThirdNet organizations regularly receive patients referred to them by hospitals and clinics.
168
00:31:34.540 --> 00:31:45.470
CSIM Presenter: In the private sector, and the two core safety nets. It is from this broader systemic framing that we began to understand these referrals as a form of patient dumping.
169
00:31:46.590 --> 00:32:00.030
CSIM Presenter: The ThirdNet becomes a convenient location to push out patients, even by safety net providers, whose mission is to care for those with low income and no insurance, and receive tax breaks in government funds to do so.
170
00:32:00.180 --> 00:32:08.720
CSIM Presenter: This is particularly the case for safety net providers living in states that did not expand Medicaid under the Affordable Care Act, but just as importantly.
171
00:32:08.720 --> 00:32:21.370
CSIM Presenter: The third net is used to hide the realities of an exclusionary infrastructure that discriminates on the basis of class, race, and immigration status. It is designed to systematically dump the most vulnerable patients.
172
00:32:23.190 --> 00:32:24.850
CSIM Presenter: Patient jump book.
173
00:32:25.860 --> 00:32:33.190
CSIM Presenter: Now, patient dumping generally refers to the transfer of a patient from a private to a public hospital for financial reasons.
174
00:32:33.190 --> 00:32:42.389
CSIM Presenter: For financial reasons. It is widely… it's a widespread practice that has existed for many, many years in the United States, so it's nothing new.
175
00:32:42.390 --> 00:32:54.809
CSIM Presenter: And in fact, as early as the 1870s, the New York Times published an expose about private hospitals using ambulances to shift poor patients to Bellevue, a public hospital.
176
00:32:54.860 --> 00:33:07.929
CSIM Presenter: Over the years, it has become increasingly institutionalized as part of our healthcare system, and yet remains a discomforting fact that garners unwanted attention for private hospitals and the larger healthcare system.
177
00:33:08.020 --> 00:33:17.870
CSIM Presenter: For instance, in April of 1986, Congress passed a federal anti-dumping legislation as part of the Consolidated Omnibus Budget Reconciliation Act.
178
00:33:18.030 --> 00:33:36.409
CSIM Presenter: And in fact, I don't know if some of you may have recalled that this 1986, legislation was passing part of some of the things that were happening in LA, right, in LA hospitals. They were literally dumping folks, patients, outside, at bus stops.
179
00:33:38.060 --> 00:33:54.149
CSIM Presenter: But this, you know, anti-dumping legislation was very limited, in terms of what it could do, to restrict hospitals from transferring a medically indigent patient while they are medically unstable.
180
00:33:54.570 --> 00:34:02.270
CSIM Presenter: Because part of the rule says that once a patient is stable, the hospital can transfer the patient for any reason, including purely financial.
181
00:34:02.290 --> 00:34:14.700
CSIM Presenter: The practice of patient dumping makes visible an unequal and segregated system of care, wherein better care for the wealthy is bolstered by shifting uncompensated costs and people to hospitals that can least afford it.
182
00:34:14.750 --> 00:34:19.210
CSIM Presenter: Safety net hospitals bear a deeply unequal distribution of these costs.
183
00:34:19.670 --> 00:34:29.970
CSIM Presenter: It is noteworthy that while this inverted pyramid illustrates the clear hierarchy of the U.S. healthcare system, it is also the case that there is regular movement across the stratified categories.
184
00:34:30.040 --> 00:34:36.380
CSIM Presenter: So organizations in the third net regularly engage the core safety net, and even the private sector
185
00:34:36.380 --> 00:34:51.729
CSIM Presenter: as the need arises. For instance, volunteer staff of a third net may be employed by local hospitals, and they draw on their personal connections to provide patients access to specialty care within the first or second net on rare occasions.
186
00:34:52.810 --> 00:34:58.469
CSIM Presenter: Now, I wanted to conclude, by going back to Houston Health Action.
187
00:34:59.430 --> 00:35:02.960
CSIM Presenter: And that's the mutual aid organization that I mentioned earlier.
188
00:35:03.310 --> 00:35:19.600
CSIM Presenter: We had interviewed members of this organization, and when we had done so in 19… I'm sorry, 19… in 2014, and then again in 2016, they had reported increasing barriers to emergency care after the implementation of the ACA.
189
00:35:19.600 --> 00:35:32.069
CSIM Presenter: They also reported worsening wait times for care. They, told us about declining quality of care in, that they received in emergency rooms and community clinics.
190
00:35:32.290 --> 00:35:46.890
CSIM Presenter: For Health Action members, their disability coupled with their immigration status make them easy targets for exclusion. Health Action members' interactions with the formal safety net are a constant reminder of this vulnerability. Within the current system.
191
00:35:47.300 --> 00:36:04.309
CSIM Presenter: policies require that their medical condition be emergencies before they can be treated. In this way, these emergencies and subsequent construction of undocumented migrants at public charges or public burdens are manufactured by the healthcare system itself.
192
00:36:04.620 --> 00:36:07.470
CSIM Presenter: Let me tell you a little bit of how this works.
193
00:36:07.590 --> 00:36:20.789
CSIM Presenter: So, we met Jose, and Jose is a Health Action member who was gravely injured in 1998 when he was struck by a car while on a bicycle on his way to work in Houston.
194
00:36:20.910 --> 00:36:25.409
CSIM Presenter: The drunk driver who had hit him fled the scene and was never identified.
195
00:36:25.670 --> 00:36:40.480
CSIM Presenter: As a result, Jose is paraplegic and relies on a wheelchair for mobility. He explained to us that one of the most profound and basic changes to his everyday life after his injury is the necessity of urinary catheters.
196
00:36:41.390 --> 00:36:48.199
CSIM Presenter: He generally needs 200 catheters a month, but the cost is prohibitive as he has little to no income.
197
00:36:48.410 --> 00:37:02.430
CSIM Presenter: Without an adequate supply, he is forced to wash and reuse the normally disposable single-use catheters repeatedly. This puts him at risk for a catheter-associated urinary tract infections, or CAUTI.
198
00:37:02.720 --> 00:37:19.299
CSIM Presenter: Although they are relatively simple plastic tubes, catheters are vital to the healthy… to the daily health and well-being of Health Action members, and a lack of access to an adequate supply of sterile catheters means that they suffer from repeat infections.
199
00:37:19.480 --> 00:37:38.930
CSIM Presenter: Denying access to catheters is counterintuitive for those concerned about healthcare costs. Although it is one of the most common healthcare-associated infections in the United States, these infections can be easily prevented through the use of sterile catheters, compared to the costs of catheters, which are about less than a dollar each.
200
00:37:39.030 --> 00:37:42.239
CSIM Presenter: Medical attention for infection is astronomical.
201
00:37:42.590 --> 00:37:52.090
CSIM Presenter: With each incidence of infection causing thousands of dollars to treat in a hospital, when treated under emergency conditions, these costs rise sharply.
202
00:37:52.720 --> 00:38:04.769
CSIM Presenter: For Jose and others, dealing with infections is a protracted ordeal. As an undocumented migrant ineligible for healthcare coverage, Jose has to be near death for his condition to be warranted in emergency.
203
00:38:04.770 --> 00:38:14.150
CSIM Presenter: At one point, when Jose visited two different area hospitals, his urinary tract infection was not considered serious enough to be an emergency, and he was turned away.
204
00:38:15.140 --> 00:38:23.520
CSIM Presenter: Due to the chronic health issues associated with his injury, Jose finds even the journey to and from the hospital to be excruciatingly painful.
205
00:38:23.580 --> 00:38:39.020
CSIM Presenter: Later, when his infection, as it does, spread to his other organs and he became gravely ill, he was taken by ambulance to the same emergency room that he had earlier been turned away and was finally given the medical care that he needed.
206
00:38:39.400 --> 00:38:49.170
CSIM Presenter: However, due to his status as an uninsured migrant, he was released from the hospital without necessary medication, which he could not afford to purchase out of pocket.
207
00:38:49.970 --> 00:39:01.899
CSIM Presenter: Another Health Action member, Samuel, described a similar set of events. Samuel's persistent urinary tract infection and lack of access to care took a toll on his body, resulting in kidney failure.
208
00:39:01.920 --> 00:39:09.220
CSIM Presenter: Samuel now requires regular dialysis, yet is deemed ineligible for dialysis, except as an emergency.
209
00:39:09.220 --> 00:39:24.219
CSIM Presenter: This means that in order to get dialysis for his kidney failure that resulted from a untreated catheter-associated urinary tract infection, Samuel has to wait until his potassium level reaches a critical point before a hospital will treat him.
210
00:39:25.010 --> 00:39:30.370
CSIM Presenter: Placing him at risk of coma or death, again and again.
211
00:39:32.380 --> 00:39:51.560
CSIM Presenter: In describing the action or interaction of health action members with the formal health system, Executive Director Diego stated, quote, good health is defined in such a way that those whose bodies do not conform are not respected. So you get used to living with pain. It's the new normal, end quote.
212
00:39:51.600 --> 00:40:02.009
CSIM Presenter: This bodily nonconformity intersects in a number of ways to produce the marginalization that they endure as uninsured, undocumented Latinx migrants with disabilities.
213
00:40:02.010 --> 00:40:15.950
CSIM Presenter: Their struggle with a lack of access to healthcare and medical supplies represents the material consequences of the racist and classist ideology of public charge that stigmatizes them as dependent, unproductive, and undeserving.
214
00:40:16.080 --> 00:40:20.819
CSIM Presenter: Health Action's critique of this system is to denaturalize the new normal.
215
00:40:20.850 --> 00:40:28.249
CSIM Presenter: By emphasizing the injustice of the current health system, and by arguing for healthcare as a public good.
216
00:40:28.260 --> 00:40:42.029
CSIM Presenter: and health access as a social justice issue. Diego stated, quote, we don't have immigration reform, we don't have healthcare reform, we have apartheid. This is an apartheid system, end quote.
217
00:40:43.030 --> 00:40:54.749
CSIM Presenter: If by measures… if measured by finances and human resources, the third net is minuscule in comparison, but its position is critical in absorbing the inherent inequality.
218
00:40:54.750 --> 00:41:05.970
CSIM Presenter: of the U.S. healthcare system, and thereby softening its impact. It appears that a dumping ground for those excluded is an essential part of the overall functioning of the U.S. healthcare system.
219
00:41:06.250 --> 00:41:07.309
CSIM Presenter: Thank you.
220
00:41:11.190 --> 00:41:25.349
CSIM Presenter: Oh, you know what? I'm… I… you'll forgive me. I realize I'm gonna have one more slide, and I'm gonna… this is a shameless plugging of my forthcoming book on medical deportation, which extends this work on the third net.
221
00:41:25.350 --> 00:41:32.990
CSIM Presenter: To think… to think about international patient dumping, what that looks like, as something that has been going on for many, many years as well.
222
00:41:33.060 --> 00:41:33.790
CSIM Presenter: Okay
223
00:41:37.410 --> 00:41:55.469
CSIM Presenter: Before we go to our discussion, I should mention that the third net is an award-winning book. It wore… it won… yes, another… It won the, it… the American Sociological Association's International Migrant Section, Thomas Donetski.
224
00:41:55.470 --> 00:42:01.860
CSIM Presenter: Best Book Award for 2025, so… Congratulations again, and Gandhi.
225
00:42:05.760 --> 00:42:07.100
CSIM Presenter: Boy. Oh, wait.
226
00:42:07.250 --> 00:42:10.160
CSIM Presenter: Is this your laptop, or is this the…
227
00:42:10.860 --> 00:42:14.939
CSIM Presenter: The room laptop. The room laptop. Okay.
228
00:42:15.110 --> 00:42:16.989
CSIM Presenter: I think I got it. There's room.
229
00:42:17.710 --> 00:42:20.669
CSIM Presenter: There we go. Hey everyone, y'all can hear me, right?
230
00:42:21.400 --> 00:42:26.030
CSIM Presenter: Okay, thank you so much for,
231
00:42:26.510 --> 00:42:28.650
CSIM Presenter: Might as well leave it open in case, yeah.
232
00:42:28.920 --> 00:42:45.499
CSIM Presenter: Thanks so much for welcoming up here to North Campus and onto campus in general. I'm on… this is a rare visit to campus during my sabbatical, but this was an opportunity that I couldn't miss to discuss Lisa's book.
233
00:42:45.720 --> 00:42:52.350
CSIM Presenter: Which is, amazing. As a recovering sociologist, now in a school of public health.
234
00:42:52.350 --> 00:43:07.260
CSIM Presenter: I support your embrace of team science and multi-authorship. You're going to a solo book next time. I thought maybe you'd go to 9 authors, and then 27 authors. Like, that's how my life has unfolded over the last 20 or so years.
235
00:43:07.260 --> 00:43:12.749
CSIM Presenter: But this was just eye-opening to see, as someone who does a lot of work on immigrant health.
236
00:43:12.800 --> 00:43:16.479
CSIM Presenter: From a different lens, but also works on…
237
00:43:16.720 --> 00:43:30.600
CSIM Presenter: with a lot of street medicine and field medicine partner institutions in the homelessness space. It was amazing to just get this gripping description of the ThirdNet as a whole, of its…
238
00:43:30.770 --> 00:43:43.619
CSIM Presenter: fascinating, kind of multifaceted, relationship with the main strip… with the first and second nets, which go beyond dumping into a lot of, you know, just the ways that
239
00:43:44.430 --> 00:43:54.270
CSIM Presenter: compassionate people fill gaps and do health diplomacy and brokering, I think, is how it's described in the book.
240
00:43:54.300 --> 00:44:01.720
CSIM Presenter: And then, of course, this nexus of the different types of institutions that inhabit the third net.
241
00:44:01.750 --> 00:44:14.299
CSIM Presenter: From charity healthcare programs that replicate the larger healthcare system, and are often led by privileged folks, to social justice organizations that are often still led by privileged folks.
242
00:44:14.300 --> 00:44:26.149
CSIM Presenter: But nonetheless strive to pursue dual goals of immigration reform and healthcare reform and building a better system. And then mutual aid organizations that are often migrant-led.
243
00:44:26.150 --> 00:44:41.619
CSIM Presenter: even more Freyan in their construction, and really… it was just… I mean, for those who haven't gotten a chance to read the book, I really… just… the chapter on the mutual aid organization is just really, really gripping.
244
00:44:42.940 --> 00:44:57.010
CSIM Presenter: Throughout the book, you get a really lived sense of the unfolding battle between those who seek to extend the second net of safety net healthcare insurers and federally qualified healthcare centers to undocumented folks.
245
00:44:57.820 --> 00:45:10.539
CSIM Presenter: to, in a sense, go back to the pre-Obamacare days, and those who only see failure and harm in the formal healthcare system, and would like to imagine something completely different. And of course, in our current political environment.
246
00:45:11.130 --> 00:45:16.579
CSIM Presenter: I don't know, it feels like all possibilities are on the table, in terms of
247
00:45:17.270 --> 00:45:33.010
CSIM Presenter: universal healthcare, which could exclude almost everyone that these organizations serve and make their lives even more difficult, to even further restrictions on the safety and well-being of undocumented populations.
248
00:45:33.500 --> 00:45:37.700
CSIM Presenter: Perhaps the most gripping depiction of that struggle
249
00:45:37.700 --> 00:45:54.459
CSIM Presenter: that ideological struggle comes in the tensions that exist not between organizations, but within the factions, kind of in the middle of the third net, we have these social justice organizations, and within the social justice organization, which she calls, community.
250
00:45:54.460 --> 00:45:56.120
CSIM Presenter: There are these…
251
00:45:56.120 --> 00:46:11.949
CSIM Presenter: factions within that organization, and you sort of get the sense of this uneasy coexistence of these two factions, one focused on clinical concerns, and one focused on justice concerns, one focused on, let's
252
00:46:11.950 --> 00:46:19.689
CSIM Presenter: meet the medical needs as best we can, one focus on let's be more holistic in our conception.
253
00:46:20.420 --> 00:46:33.089
CSIM Presenter: Focusing on the case of diabetes, Dr. Park draws this sort of obvious tension between those who would just say, let's prioritize the patients with the most severe presentation of diabetic condition.
254
00:46:35.590 --> 00:46:46.489
CSIM Presenter: versus those who would want to contextualize this within a lifetime of exposure to violence and other forms of social and political harms.
255
00:46:46.790 --> 00:47:06.009
CSIM Presenter: that may not appear in the diagnostic materials, but would be equally worthy of care. And of course, within all of this, these are generally groups of people who agree that all needs should be met, and yet the battle over which ones to prioritize spills over to the extent that they actually sort of end up oper…
256
00:47:06.130 --> 00:47:14.949
CSIM Presenter: Occupying different days of clinic, where one day is more led by the justice-oriented group and one by the, clinically-oriented group.
257
00:47:15.520 --> 00:47:32.960
CSIM Presenter: And so in that regard, I was curious whether there were much sort of conversations about how people frame the social determinants of health. So in the street medicine spaces that I work in that are focused on the needs of unhoused communities, there have been systematic efforts to incorporate the negative social determinants of health
258
00:47:32.960 --> 00:47:47.449
CSIM Presenter: into screening tools, even into the, you know, there's all kinds of ICD codes that recognize a wide variety of social determinants of health, including homelessness, including, undocumented legal status, including violence.
259
00:47:47.650 --> 00:48:04.009
CSIM Presenter: And these kind of screening tools are not without controversy, right? Since some would view them as just another way to co-opt social justice framing, and social justice language, and those commitments that we have, and putting them into another clinical bucket.
260
00:48:04.060 --> 00:48:22.190
CSIM Presenter: And yet, for many organizations, they do represent a kind of way to split the difference and maybe build a bridge, right? For us, working in the homelessness street medicine space, what that's amounted to is that now we're getting closer and closer to the day that a doctor can write a prescription for housing.
261
00:48:22.190 --> 00:48:28.770
CSIM Presenter: Now, obviously, that's in a system where people have rights and access to… that's in the second net.
262
00:48:30.390 --> 00:48:43.970
CSIM Presenter: But it's just to say it's one of the kinds of tools that organizations use to bridge some of these divides, to come up with practical kind of clutches to work through some of these conflicts.
263
00:48:44.130 --> 00:48:59.920
CSIM Presenter: At that level, though, I was also just curious about, you know, how do these organizations even keep medical records? Like, what are the record… what do the records look like? I sort of say, oh, social determinants of health screening, ICD codes, but are these the kinds of things that they're tracking? Do they use electronic systems?
264
00:48:59.980 --> 00:49:15.969
CSIM Presenter: How are identities linked across visits, especially given serious concerns about confidentiality, about being rated, about people's level of trust, if you collect a bunch of data on them, which is a constant struggle that our provider partners face?
265
00:49:15.970 --> 00:49:26.510
CSIM Presenter: It was notable in that telling that community actually took real pride in knowing how many patients they served, rather than how many encounters they had.
266
00:49:26.510 --> 00:49:30.619
CSIM Presenter: And this made me smile, because I spent the last decade
267
00:49:30.620 --> 00:49:34.320
CSIM Presenter: Imploring our homeless services provider colleagues
268
00:49:34.320 --> 00:49:54.520
CSIM Presenter: to think not in terms of encounters with this person, who may or may not be the same person I've seen before, but instead to think in terms of a person. And when I see you, I'm doing it proactively. I'm doing it from a standpoint of knowing who you are, but that requires a level of trust and a willingness to share data, and of course, systems to collect those data.
269
00:49:55.380 --> 00:50:03.759
CSIM Presenter: Then on the other side of that, so that's sort of the, say, the downstream consequences of health for social determinants.
270
00:50:03.970 --> 00:50:11.809
CSIM Presenter: On the other side, I'm curious about how these organizations engage in what we'd call culturally informed preventative care.
271
00:50:11.960 --> 00:50:30.169
CSIM Presenter: So, in my Master's of Public Health, I teach Intro to Program Design and Evaluation courses, and every year there's a few groups who are designing… whose project is to design culturally informed prevention programs for vulnerable populations, including undocumented people. Most of them are focused on the metabolic spectrum.
272
00:50:30.290 --> 00:50:48.460
CSIM Presenter: Or diabetes, if not diabetes in particular. And many of the social justice healthcare forerunners of an organization like Community, whether that's the Black Panthers or the Cuban healthcare system, have focused on prevention, so healthy diet, exercise.
273
00:50:48.460 --> 00:51:00.160
CSIM Presenter: As a key component of maintaining, essentially, bodily resilience in order to build, right, that community resilience, cultural resilience, political resistance, come from,
274
00:51:00.380 --> 00:51:02.940
CSIM Presenter: healthy and safe bodies.
275
00:51:03.190 --> 00:51:19.979
CSIM Presenter: And in the book, I saw a lot of examples of staff engaging in all manner of social and cultural care to address basic needs, to overcome administrative barriers, and to address all the political and social threats that undocumented people are facing in all directions.
276
00:51:19.980 --> 00:51:24.110
CSIM Presenter: But it was striking in that sense, you know, that
277
00:51:24.110 --> 00:51:41.619
CSIM Presenter: that there weren't… there was no talk of prevention or programming. And you could imagine that the reason for that would be that, well, they're too busy dealing with basic needs and putting out fires. But I'm curious whether there were sort of prevention interventions, whether people were thinking about prevention, whether it was just kind of off the table.
278
00:51:41.690 --> 00:51:52.290
CSIM Presenter: And particularly, perhaps, in that light of the debate between the clinically oriented and the justice-oriented groups.
279
00:51:53.130 --> 00:52:05.320
CSIM Presenter: Finally, I just want to go to your conclusion, which sort of focused… it's a really amazing kind of discussion of all the potentialities of healthcare reform, and really just an illustration of the trap.
280
00:52:05.630 --> 00:52:11.770
CSIM Presenter: That… that we're in, and that… that undocumented communities face right now in the U.S.
281
00:52:13.150 --> 00:52:25.319
CSIM Presenter: So it addressed the, you know, potential restoration of safety net access, the debate about whether this would even be a good thing or not, as well as all the threats around the horizon. And again, most of this fieldwork took place
282
00:52:25.440 --> 00:52:30.630
CSIM Presenter: prior for all of the fieldwork, I think, took place prior to the current, political.
283
00:52:30.930 --> 00:52:32.530
CSIM Presenter: Crisis that we're in.
284
00:52:33.210 --> 00:52:41.799
CSIM Presenter: Fast forwarding to, you know, 5 years or so, to the current context, on the one hand, undocumented communities are under unimaginable threat.
285
00:52:41.910 --> 00:52:58.119
CSIM Presenter: On the other hand, universal healthcare is now a widely discussed option, but again, we can think about all the ways that that would just manifest as an expansion of the same broken system, or as a system that would exclude undocumented people.
286
00:52:59.200 --> 00:53:01.670
CSIM Presenter: I also just want to note that
287
00:53:02.030 --> 00:53:18.149
CSIM Presenter: Dr. Park mentions in the context of public charge how ridiculous it is that, say, public charge excludes many undocumented migrants who are obviously sort of net contributors to the workforce and to finance… to public finance systems. Fast-forwarding 5 years, though.
288
00:53:18.570 --> 00:53:25.190
CSIM Presenter: So… Those… those situations have changed as well.
289
00:53:25.470 --> 00:53:40.039
CSIM Presenter: Right? At the time, 5 years ago, it would have been really insane, and only a sort of bad political actor would be claiming that undocumented migrants were a burden. But fast forward 5 years, the undocumented population has aged significantly.
290
00:53:40.130 --> 00:53:51.850
CSIM Presenter: Right? My PhD student, Sandra Garcia, who maybe is on Zoom, I don't know if she shouts if she is, but she's furiously trying to finish her dissertation on retirement preparedness of domestic workers.
291
00:53:51.850 --> 00:54:06.549
CSIM Presenter: And this sort of rising tide, demographically, of domestic workers who came, you know, who were all… many of whom came here young and are now, much older. And it's not just that they've gotten older, right? It's that they are
292
00:54:07.470 --> 00:54:16.129
CSIM Presenter: Broken down by years of precarious work, occupational injury, exclusion, socioeconomic burdens that leave them without any retirement income.
293
00:54:16.310 --> 00:54:25.700
CSIM Presenter: Right? Many undocumented families who go on 5 years without any preventative care, which creates a backlog of unaddressed healthcare needs, not least of which is diabetes.
294
00:54:25.700 --> 00:54:39.770
CSIM Presenter: Many have families that were fragmented by COVID-19 and other socioeconomic threats. We've been tracking the dramatic rise in homelessness, especially working homelessness and vehicular homelessness, among Latinx people in LA County.
295
00:54:41.200 --> 00:54:52.369
CSIM Presenter: And so, in short, while there are many young undocumented migrants, especially those who are DACA eligible, and also sort of fit into this bucket where some deem them more worthy.
296
00:54:52.370 --> 00:55:01.689
CSIM Presenter: There could also be more full-throated calls, both of the hateful variety and of the fiscally prudent variety, to cut off all undocumented people, or certain people.
297
00:55:01.690 --> 00:55:05.259
CSIM Presenter: from any kind of Medicaid… Medicare for All program.
298
00:55:05.260 --> 00:55:24.980
CSIM Presenter: And so, how should immigrant health advocates approach this delicate conversation? How do people in the community think about it? I just wondered if you could reflect on that. And then, the last is just to come back to LA, I always take a very LA-centric perspective on these things, and it feels like so much of what makes this book
299
00:55:24.990 --> 00:55:38.879
CSIM Presenter: interesting is that it's not set in California, right? That it's set in Texas and Arizona, where there is a very different environment of Medicaid expansion, but also of state-level entitlements than what we have in California.
300
00:55:38.880 --> 00:55:49.639
CSIM Presenter: California is becoming a lot, right, just as Texas may have Medicaid expansion before too long, California is retreating from a lot of its extraordinary commitments, most notably in July.
301
00:55:49.780 --> 00:56:10.789
CSIM Presenter: there will be the beginning of what we think will be a series of restrictions of expanding Medi-Cal access for immigrant communities. And at the same time, right, you know, my… another shout-out to another of my students, Juan Delgado, an undergrad here at UCLA who's now doing an MPH at Berkeley, just submitted a paper showing widespread withdrawal.
302
00:56:10.790 --> 00:56:17.079
CSIM Presenter: from healthcare services among foreign-born and Latinx respondents who were not necessarily immigrants.
303
00:56:17.080 --> 00:56:21.949
CSIM Presenter: Even particularly among those who had previously never avoided healthcare.
304
00:56:21.950 --> 00:56:31.569
CSIM Presenter: So, in short, if LA is becoming more like Phoenix and Houston, what are some principles of action for organizers, advocates, and clinicians?
305
00:56:31.770 --> 00:56:41.549
CSIM Presenter: That's right, that's a lot of questions. Feel free to just pick and choose. This was… or not answer them at all. This was amazing. Thank you, for the opportunity to discuss.
306
00:56:50.710 --> 00:57:06.070
CSIM Presenter: Thank you so much. Those are an amazing set of, ideas and thoughts and questions, and… and I'd love to just sort of go through so many of them, but I… But I'll just touch on a few things, right? And I'll start off,
307
00:57:06.260 --> 00:57:12.889
CSIM Presenter: Going back to, the point about the struggles within the organizations,
308
00:57:13.490 --> 00:57:20.620
CSIM Presenter: which were really interesting, right? And we wanted to be sure to convey
309
00:57:20.730 --> 00:57:27.209
CSIM Presenter: that there is no quick fix here. Like, none of these organizations, right,
310
00:57:29.240 --> 00:57:31.620
CSIM Presenter: Know exactly what they're doing at all times.
311
00:57:31.830 --> 00:57:48.999
CSIM Presenter: Right? I mean, each one of them are imperfect, and there is a constant struggle, right? So, at the same time that they are absolutely giving it their all. So, you see an incredible level of commitment, whether it's, you know, grace in Action, which is
312
00:57:49.210 --> 00:58:05.160
CSIM Presenter: very, like, religious-forward organization, and in fact, you know, when we first went there, it felt a little jarring compared to some of the other organizations that we had visited, and… because it was towards the tail end when we visited them.
313
00:58:05.160 --> 00:58:15.950
CSIM Presenter: And unlike the other organizations, just in the way that they dressed, the folks who were, giving us the tour and initially met… sat with us for the interview.
314
00:58:16.740 --> 00:58:27.780
CSIM Presenter: I mean, these are serious church ladies with church lady outfits on, like flower dresses and heels, right? And it felt a little disconcerting, in part because we had been meeting with, like.
315
00:58:27.930 --> 00:58:42.319
CSIM Presenter: Activists with their grunge outfits and, you know, like, the whole thing, and it's… it's fascinating, the variation across, and then within the organization, there's this constant, you know, working and reworking of, like, what… what do we stand for?
316
00:58:42.320 --> 00:58:49.420
CSIM Presenter: what are our priorities? We don't… we will never have enough, so given what little we do.
317
00:58:49.600 --> 00:59:11.659
CSIM Presenter: how do we best use our resources, right? So, and the people themselves change so quickly, right? The turnover rate in these organizations is intense, and I would say this across all the safety nets, right? Where we're talking first, second, or third, right? When we first went out to 2014, and then we came… went back out to 2016, we tried to go and meet
318
00:59:11.660 --> 00:59:16.480
CSIM Presenter: With the same people, but it was impossible, because over 50% were already gone.
319
00:59:16.580 --> 00:59:19.120
CSIM Presenter: Right? Because this is a tough job.
320
00:59:19.560 --> 00:59:26.119
CSIM Presenter: across the board, right? You're having to figure out, and on, you know, problem solving.
321
00:59:26.550 --> 00:59:32.800
CSIM Presenter: with few resources, and with some serious issues, right? So, this is not an easy job.
322
00:59:33.190 --> 00:59:41.940
CSIM Presenter: having said that, right, there are some ways that they can certainly improve, right? You can say that about everyone, too, right?
323
00:59:43.600 --> 00:59:47.470
CSIM Presenter: In terms of, you know, and one of the… the…
324
00:59:47.830 --> 00:59:55.109
CSIM Presenter: The serious amount of debates that happen internally is, you know.
325
00:59:55.490 --> 01:00:02.480
CSIM Presenter: what do we fix and how, right? Like, what does it mean? Do we treat the person, right? Or are we treating a larger
326
01:00:02.490 --> 01:00:22.580
CSIM Presenter: community, or is this, a larger societal issue, right? And how we frame that depend… you know, also impacts sort of how we approach this, right? So, so how does, like, the social determinants of health, get incorporated? It could look very different from one organization to another.
327
01:00:22.580 --> 01:00:23.180
CSIM Presenter: Right?
328
01:00:25.440 --> 01:00:41.920
CSIM Presenter: One other note I'll make is, I love the fact that you mentioned medical records. How does one keep them? It is fascinating. This one bored me, right? Because, again, incredible variation, and almost nobody keeps… there's no electronic record.
329
01:00:42.110 --> 01:00:46.190
CSIM Presenter: But there's no, like… we're talking good ol', like.
330
01:00:46.390 --> 01:01:05.210
CSIM Presenter: vanilla folders with handwritten notes that's in a, these little, rolling trolleys, because these, files have to be able to be stored very easily, and for many of these,
331
01:01:05.430 --> 01:01:07.819
CSIM Presenter: 3rdNet organizations.
332
01:01:07.820 --> 01:01:30.809
CSIM Presenter: they don't even have a building of their own. They don't have a facility of their own. Most of them have to re… basically repurpose another building that exists. It could be a church. One case, it's a church. It's in another place, it's a social service organization, but they close their doors at 5, right? And so they come in once a week.
333
01:01:30.810 --> 01:01:39.439
CSIM Presenter: at… starting at 5.30, right? And then they're allowed to have one little closet where they store all their medical records, right? And then they pull it out.
334
01:01:39.680 --> 01:02:02.920
CSIM Presenter: So, they also… this is also a way, of course, to protect the confidentiality, and there is no, record of whether or not one is… what kind of citizenship one has, although there's that one unique, you know, organization that I mentioned in the beginning that actually had a sign that said… tried to restrict anybody who's not undocumented, because they were being flooded
335
01:02:02.920 --> 01:02:10.989
CSIM Presenter: with people of… who have citizenship. Some of them have health insurance, are trying to come to that clinic, in part because they're treated with respect.
336
01:02:11.090 --> 01:02:24.029
CSIM Presenter: they are treated with kindness, and they're treated as people. And so you have people who have insurance trying to get in, right? And that's the reason why they have that sign, right? Because they're trying to basically try to figure out who has
337
01:02:24.110 --> 01:02:36.229
CSIM Presenter: who has insurance so they can leave, right? Not trying to figure out if you don't have insurance and trying to make you leave. It's sort of the opposite, scenario. And finally, I'll make a note that,
338
01:02:37.570 --> 01:02:41.739
CSIM Presenter: You know, about culturally informed prevention programs.
339
01:02:42.390 --> 01:02:49.050
CSIM Presenter: So… One of the things that we saw, on several occasions, or several of these organizations, is that
340
01:02:49.160 --> 01:02:59.209
CSIM Presenter: As I mentioned, every one of them, the wait lines are enormous. There's… it's so hard to make an appointment. For many, they can't. Some are able to, but many cannot.
341
01:02:59.350 --> 01:03:03.400
CSIM Presenter: So all… like so much of poverty governance in general.
342
01:03:03.470 --> 01:03:23.019
CSIM Presenter: Life is about waiting on everybody else's time, right? And you're lucky to be seen, and you're supposed to be literally lucky. You're always supposed to enact gratitude, right? Despite the fact that you have now lost a whole day's worth of work, right? That is significant. Now you have all your kids with you, right? Because you…
343
01:03:23.140 --> 01:03:42.559
CSIM Presenter: how are you going to find a daycare, right? And so you've got children who are… are not… who haven't had enough food, who don't have much… you know, who are, after a long day, are coming in, you know, at 9 p.m. Some of these clinics are open quite late. So these are… but one of the things that we notice is that when it's those long wait times.
344
01:03:42.740 --> 01:03:45.260
CSIM Presenter: That's when the health education happens.
345
01:03:45.380 --> 01:04:01.429
CSIM Presenter: So then you have organizations and other folks who are working with immigrant communities, or maybe just working on nutrition, or other kinds of, kinds of services that come in, and that's when they do, like.
346
01:04:01.680 --> 01:04:24.229
CSIM Presenter: like, cooking, like, talk about diabetes care, they talk about, all kinds of, sort of, preventative things that are low-hanging fruit, if you will, in terms of healthcare, but have… could have significant impacts in one's life, right? So, I feel like there is a really, efficient use
347
01:04:24.230 --> 01:04:29.309
CSIM Presenter: Right? Of all resources, right? Including wait times, right? That happens.
348
01:04:29.310 --> 01:04:32.660
CSIM Presenter: As well as they also hire people… not…
349
01:04:32.660 --> 01:04:51.429
CSIM Presenter: they get volunteers, I should say, from local colleges and high schools who come in and to help care for the children, so that the children, they also have reading time with the kids, right? So that, again, they could be waiting for hours, right? And so what are the kids are going to do? So they come in with snacks, and they have, like, reading hour, or something like that. So, I mean, there are different things that are done.
350
01:04:51.430 --> 01:04:55.659
CSIM Presenter: But it is also… you're also correct, Randall, in noting that
351
01:04:55.740 --> 01:04:59.820
CSIM Presenter: You know, sort of preventative programs in terms of, let's say.
352
01:05:00.720 --> 01:05:07.100
CSIM Presenter: What individual, folks can do in terms of prevention is not something that anyone ever talked about.
353
01:05:07.480 --> 01:05:22.120
CSIM Presenter: Right? Because they're very focused on structural, right? You could talk about nutrition all you want, and in fact, it's not that they're against it, right? But they're, again, limited resources, but also their focus, right, is on food access in general.
354
01:05:22.530 --> 01:05:24.940
CSIM Presenter: Right? Never mind nutrition.
355
01:05:25.150 --> 01:05:34.769
CSIM Presenter: Right? So their kind of hierarchy of, sort of, needs, right, and their focus, right, is, I think structural in that way.
356
01:05:34.900 --> 01:05:44.060
CSIM Presenter: Okay, so I think I'll stop there for now and, get other questions from… those…
357
01:05:47.740 --> 01:05:49.100
CSIM Presenter: Yeah, yeah.
358
01:05:49.390 --> 01:05:59.080
CSIM Presenter: Thank you so much for your presentation. I think, it adds a lot of understanding to migration infrastructure, and also migration industry.
359
01:05:59.190 --> 01:06:05.260
CSIM Presenter: So you can see that, a lot of the actors here are actually not for-profit, so I found that really…
360
01:06:05.350 --> 01:06:08.799
CSIM Presenter: hard to know. I have a question,
361
01:06:08.850 --> 01:06:28.219
CSIM Presenter: what you describe as the positive disarray of care. So it seems like the three philosophies of care, the charity, the social justice, and the mutual aid, they're disjointed in their own space. I was wondering why do you not see more international or collaboration come often?
362
01:06:28.220 --> 01:06:34.990
CSIM Presenter: Or even, like, you know, two kinds of philosophies converge? Why are they so separate?
363
01:06:36.350 --> 01:06:45.150
CSIM Presenter: Yeah, I think there are a couple of reasons, and that's a really good question. And it goes to some of the core,
364
01:06:47.040 --> 01:06:50.900
CSIM Presenter: missions, right? And the purpose of these organizations.
365
01:06:51.630 --> 01:07:00.300
CSIM Presenter: And that is that, on the one hand, It is a… patchwork.
366
01:07:00.790 --> 01:07:02.190
CSIM Presenter: because…
367
01:07:03.730 --> 01:07:12.480
CSIM Presenter: Because the formal system does not want to make visible and acknowledge that we have incredible amount of unmet needs.
368
01:07:12.700 --> 01:07:19.830
CSIM Presenter: That we are not fulfilling our duty, right, as the global leader Or…
369
01:07:19.860 --> 01:07:35.740
CSIM Presenter: pretend global leader, or whatever it is, right? Of, like, medical technologies and of medical care, right? And in fact, we have an incredibly inefficient system in the United States of care, right? We, spend more than any other, you know.
370
01:07:35.740 --> 01:07:41.290
CSIM Presenter: country, and yet the kind of care that we receive in the United States is subpar.
371
01:07:41.340 --> 01:07:53.519
CSIM Presenter: Right? So, it was… it's not pretty, right? And on top of that, when you have millions of people, right, who are not… who are not being served, right, in
372
01:07:53.640 --> 01:07:59.740
CSIM Presenter: It shows the level of inequality, right, and inefficiencies, this is not a good look.
373
01:07:59.900 --> 01:08:07.790
CSIM Presenter: For us, right? I mean, there's something so absurd, right? Like, you could be in Houston, where you have one of the
374
01:08:07.900 --> 01:08:19.530
CSIM Presenter: global centers of medical technology and innovation. Like, massive high-rises of care, different kinds of, you know.
375
01:08:19.540 --> 01:08:31.510
CSIM Presenter: all the big names, they have major offices and sometimes headquarters there, right? And yet you have millions of people who live right next door who cannot get the basic care, right?
376
01:08:31.510 --> 01:08:44.859
CSIM Presenter: Like, this is a huge problem, right? This is a glaring social problem, and this is not something we'd like to kind of show. So, that kind of disparate kind of disarray, right? That's what I mean by being purposeful.
377
01:08:44.890 --> 01:08:50.210
CSIM Presenter: Now, within the community clinics themselves, or within the third net, right?
378
01:08:50.420 --> 01:08:58.659
CSIM Presenter: There… there's very little conversation, in part, right? Because there's… there… these are not employed
379
01:08:58.920 --> 01:09:10.839
CSIM Presenter: people. They have other jobs, right? Many of… almost all of them do, although some of them are retired, but even the retired folks have busy lives, right? But they're doing this, as a volunteer.
380
01:09:11.010 --> 01:09:13.979
CSIM Presenter: So, when you do not have,
381
01:09:14.479 --> 01:09:27.549
CSIM Presenter: you know, formally, or formal paid folks to do things like connect with other clinics and things like this, it's just hard to do that. You know, one of the interesting things,
382
01:09:27.930 --> 01:09:34.949
CSIM Presenter: Was… was meeting each clinic and… or, organization, and they would always ask us.
383
01:09:35.060 --> 01:09:48.600
CSIM Presenter: So, what did you find? What are they doing in Houston? Or, I mean, in Arizona? What are they doing? Meet people in Albuquerque, and they're like, wait, what's happening in California? You know, so it was fascinating that we were the ones going, okay, let me tell you that, you know, this is happening over here.
384
01:09:48.910 --> 01:09:53.139
CSIM Presenter: But it's also the case that some, we also saw
385
01:09:53.479 --> 01:09:58.490
CSIM Presenter: The effectiveness of these organizations is because it's so hyper-local, too.
386
01:09:58.730 --> 01:10:15.629
CSIM Presenter: Right? The level of trust, right, is hyperlocal, right? And that's really important. That's the part where you see people as people, and your neighbors, right? And not necessarily as patient encounters, right? And that is really important.
387
01:10:15.630 --> 01:10:32.690
CSIM Presenter: I should also note that the network of people, that they have over these many years, they facilitated, came in handy for a lot of different emergencies, like, not just health-related. So, the mutual aid organization that I mentioned earlier.
388
01:10:32.860 --> 01:10:45.209
CSIM Presenter: That organization, because they have worked so hard, right, not only on, sort of, the healthcare-related kind of provision of, like, catheters and other equipment, health-related equipment.
389
01:10:45.310 --> 01:10:59.389
CSIM Presenter: But in the kinds of relationships that they have fostered and the trust that they have really built, over the years, well, when there was a hurricane, as there is repeatedly, right, in Houston.
390
01:10:59.480 --> 01:11:13.300
CSIM Presenter: as well as COVID-19, right? Guess what? The county actually came to this mutual aid organization and said, help us to actually, send out these,
391
01:11:13.390 --> 01:11:27.600
CSIM Presenter: face masks and testing kits, because we don't have access, because they had cut off, over and over again, right, their access to the immigrant community. Not just the undocumented, but to the immigrant community, who are low-income. And guess what? They became suddenly essential.
392
01:11:27.910 --> 01:11:35.759
CSIM Presenter: Right? And when these folks became essential to, like, food delivery, to the other kinds of ways in which to exist at a
393
01:11:35.900 --> 01:11:55.359
CSIM Presenter: basic level as a society, right? Suddenly they became important, and suddenly we didn't… we needed them to be able to continue to deliver our groceries, right? And so then they came to this mutual aid organization and helped us, and they asked them to help them to distribute the goods, and they did, and they were incredibly effective.
394
01:11:55.420 --> 01:11:57.750
CSIM Presenter: So… Thank you for the question.
395
01:12:04.800 --> 01:12:11.480
CSIM Presenter: Any other questions, comments? We have one…
396
01:12:11.820 --> 01:12:18.990
CSIM Presenter: One question. We're going to read… Okay, so the question is…
397
01:12:19.160 --> 01:12:33.639
CSIM Presenter: Thank you so much for this presentation. I'm actually here because I work for a nonprofit that provides preventative healthcare to refugees and migrant communities, amongst other underrepresented communities in SoCal. We would love to speak to you…
398
01:12:34.100 --> 01:12:45.699
CSIM Presenter: Oh, okay, they're asking for a separate conversation, I think, about improving efforts and to better help these communities. So yeah, I'm happy to give you the email, no problem.
399
01:12:46.020 --> 01:12:54.049
CSIM Presenter: And, absolutely, I… we are happy to help. And we are…
400
01:12:54.690 --> 01:12:58.160
CSIM Presenter: I… so maybe I'll just say, since I have a few minutes,
401
01:12:58.350 --> 01:13:09.799
CSIM Presenter: you know, especially post, COVID, I did, go back to some of these organizations to check in on them, to see how things were going. And…
402
01:13:10.990 --> 01:13:16.840
CSIM Presenter: Unfortunately, I've just, you know, a number of the organizations do not exist anymore.
403
01:13:16.900 --> 01:13:25.449
CSIM Presenter: And we were not able to follow up with them to understand why exactly. I think there might be different reasons, I could imagine.
404
01:13:25.450 --> 01:13:33.239
CSIM Presenter: Some of them do exist, but the folks who are running them are entirely a different group of people.
405
01:13:33.240 --> 01:13:48.269
CSIM Presenter: And I've noticed that with different groups of people who are now running it, the kind of mission has also adapted, right? And that's what happens when you have a volunteer organization, right? There isn't sort of an established charter somewhere that says this is sort of the goals, and you have folks who
406
01:13:49.140 --> 01:13:55.350
CSIM Presenter: you know, kind of create that kind of level of stability. But… you know.
407
01:13:55.860 --> 01:13:58.339
CSIM Presenter: Instead, you have different groups of people.
408
01:13:58.590 --> 01:14:07.859
CSIM Presenter: the mission changes as the people changes, right? Which is not always a bad thing, necessarily, right? But at the same time, you could imagine,
409
01:14:08.090 --> 01:14:13.410
CSIM Presenter: with the current… you know, Trump administration, how things…
410
01:14:13.780 --> 01:14:32.470
CSIM Presenter: are even more difficult, and for those who are… who have been existing largely underground, meaning are unlicensed, right, are being extremely careful about, the work that they do, and in order to make sure that they can continue, right, in some… in… in…
411
01:14:32.590 --> 01:14:41.759
CSIM Presenter: one fashion or another, right? So I see them adapting, right? In order to be able to exist and to be able to,
412
01:14:42.000 --> 01:14:45.049
CSIM Presenter: yeah, to be here post-Trump.
413
01:14:45.530 --> 01:14:47.829
CSIM Presenter: And there will be a post-Trump, so…
414
01:14:51.020 --> 01:14:59.880
CSIM Presenter: I, I think with the fact that they don't exist anymore, underscores the… the… the…
415
01:15:00.520 --> 01:15:10.240
CSIM Presenter: flux, and the informality, in the changing conditions that you document in the book itself, that this is not a thing.
416
01:15:10.380 --> 01:15:15.319
CSIM Presenter: structure, formal, part of any systems. This is… these functions
417
01:15:15.600 --> 01:15:18.809
CSIM Presenter: On… completely on a different way of all.
418
01:15:19.220 --> 01:15:28.730
CSIM Presenter: Outside of something that we… They don't even have offices, so this is… shows that… Go ahead.
419
01:15:29.530 --> 01:15:34.629
CSIM Presenter: It's not flexibility, it's just… Adaptation flucts all the time.
420
01:15:34.930 --> 01:15:39.039
CSIM Presenter: Yeah. And so it's… I'm not surprised that they don't… it was…
421
01:15:39.230 --> 01:15:45.370
CSIM Presenter: They don't exist the way you study them, but that… It shows my view.
422
01:15:45.520 --> 01:15:48.049
CSIM Presenter: Number 6, when he's showing the book.
423
01:15:48.790 --> 01:16:06.680
CSIM Presenter: I have a quick question for you. I'm very interested in this one. Oh, yes. So, if you can give us a tiny little teaser, because it is sort of like the continuation of the third net in many ways, I think, but I don't know, so…
424
01:16:06.780 --> 01:16:16.089
CSIM Presenter: Of course, yes. It's coming in… coming out in July 2027. Yes, July 2027, it's a new book.
425
01:16:16.330 --> 01:16:22.410
CSIM Presenter: But before talking about that, I will, just to follow up on your other comment,
426
01:16:22.540 --> 01:16:29.020
CSIM Presenter: About, how these… you know, ThirdNet organizations no longer exist.
427
01:16:30.070 --> 01:16:41.709
CSIM Presenter: I am absolutely sure that other ThirdNet organizations… organizations do exist now, right? That we were able to… that we didn't capture then, but exist now. And… and…
428
01:16:41.710 --> 01:17:00.190
CSIM Presenter: That is… absolutely, it's the fluctuation, it's… that is… that caters to the kinds of political moment and the context and… of that time, right? It's the nature. Yes, it is absolutely the nature of the third net, right? That it's something that you do not want it to be.
429
01:17:00.200 --> 01:17:16.899
CSIM Presenter: static, right? Because then it doesn't fulfill its purpose, right? And I should note that there are real… they're absolutely important purpose of the other safety nets, too, right? Absolutely… we absolutely need them, right? But you can see how that there is an also this
430
01:17:16.900 --> 01:17:24.180
CSIM Presenter: additional net, right, that is incredibly important that we forget about, right? That is sort of part of this sort of universe, right?
431
01:17:24.180 --> 01:17:33.109
CSIM Presenter: Okay. So, few words about this new, project. It was…
432
01:17:33.720 --> 01:17:41.020
CSIM Presenter: you know, so I started this project actually at the same time with the third netbook, right? So, because we were going…
433
01:17:41.410 --> 01:17:52.989
CSIM Presenter: Because what… so in 2014, we're sort of knocking on people's doors, basically, and we're sitting down with them, and we knew we had to do it in person.
434
01:17:53.140 --> 01:18:00.229
CSIM Presenter: Because you cannot… Work on issues about undocumented folks.
435
01:18:00.600 --> 01:18:17.630
CSIM Presenter: And we weren't even talking to… like, most of our project, by the way, we were not talking to actual undocumented patients or anything, right? We were talking to the care providers, right? And organizational, sort of, leaders, some of whom may be undocumented, but we don't know, right? Not necessarily. So…
436
01:18:18.860 --> 01:18:26.549
CSIM Presenter: So, because we were sort of having these face-to-face conversations and going from one organization to another.
437
01:18:26.990 --> 01:18:33.089
CSIM Presenter: You know, one of the things we heard repeatedly, right, was… Well, you know.
438
01:18:33.170 --> 01:18:39.900
CSIM Presenter: so-and-so just got deported, right? They would tell us this, and we kept going, wait, what are you talking about?
439
01:18:39.940 --> 01:18:58.900
CSIM Presenter: like, from… we just assumed when they were saying that, that they were talking about immigration authorities deporting immigrants, right? But no, we've become… quickly realized that's not what they're talking about. What they're talking about is that medical hospitals and clinics are deporting patients that they don't want to pay for.
440
01:18:59.070 --> 01:19:01.619
CSIM Presenter: Right? To other countries.
441
01:19:01.920 --> 01:19:04.109
CSIM Presenter: against consent?
442
01:19:04.790 --> 01:19:14.310
CSIM Presenter: and against their will, right? So, so… and many times what happened was The hospitals were calling ICE.
443
01:19:14.470 --> 01:19:18.340
CSIM Presenter: Trying to get this… Patient out of their hospital.
444
01:19:18.980 --> 01:19:23.099
CSIM Presenter: Which is… A huge red flag.
445
01:19:23.460 --> 01:19:29.980
CSIM Presenter: And the… and this is not just by me, this biased, you know, immigration bleeding heart.
446
01:19:30.210 --> 01:19:41.819
CSIM Presenter: But this is, like, against serious violations of, like, medical code of ethics, right? The AMA, you know, and the Medical Association has been pretty clear, like, you're supposed to treat, right,
447
01:19:41.990 --> 01:19:49.529
CSIM Presenter: people, right, and not… You know, not treat them because of their immigration status.
448
01:19:49.760 --> 01:20:01.689
CSIM Presenter: However, of course, it does happen, and it's done in other ways, through policy, but in any case, what we find is that hospitals are, forcibly removing
449
01:20:01.890 --> 01:20:03.850
CSIM Presenter: Severely injured.
450
01:20:04.160 --> 01:20:07.939
CSIM Presenter: Immigrant patients to other countries, many times against their will.
451
01:20:08.720 --> 01:20:15.060
CSIM Presenter: And what we did, so then what I did is to follow up on this to figure out
452
01:20:15.210 --> 01:20:18.370
CSIM Presenter: every case that I could find, right, of this.
453
01:20:18.810 --> 01:20:25.430
CSIM Presenter: It was incredibly difficult because It is not something that any,
454
01:20:25.700 --> 01:20:32.509
CSIM Presenter: hospital ever has to report. There's no record of this, right? This is simply called a transfer.
455
01:20:33.580 --> 01:20:53.240
CSIM Presenter: And hospitals transfer patients all the time. That is our normal part of any medical facility, pretty much, right? Because sometimes you'll have certain kinds of care available, or expertise, and then they don't have, you know, they're going to have to move. So they move the patients, right? So.
456
01:20:53.550 --> 01:21:07.359
CSIM Presenter: That's not unusual. What is sort of shocking in this case is that, they removed them out of the country, and the many times the ICE agent or the other immigration authority has declined to remove that patient.
457
01:21:07.360 --> 01:21:31.849
CSIM Presenter: The reason why they do that is because when they're severely injured, the federal government has to take on the price, the cost of their medical care, because they become within their custody. So many times, they do not want these patients. They will deport other people, but they do not want to deport these folks, because they're severely injured, and they have high, potentially high medical costs, and long-term care, even, on top of that. So what happens is that hospitals then procure
458
01:21:31.850 --> 01:21:34.620
CSIM Presenter: private,
459
01:21:35.000 --> 01:21:44.729
CSIM Presenter: planes and other transportation companies to come and take them, sometimes literally on a stretcher, and,
460
01:21:45.000 --> 01:21:56.980
CSIM Presenter: drop them off in the middle of Nicaragua, the Philippines, they've done this in Ukraine, they're doing this in… across, mostly in, from what I… all I could… from what I could gather.
461
01:21:57.100 --> 01:22:01.390
CSIM Presenter: to Latin American countries, in part because it's quicker, it's closer.
462
01:22:01.660 --> 01:22:05.740
CSIM Presenter: But on top of that,
463
01:22:06.110 --> 01:22:15.729
CSIM Presenter: We see it happening in Asia, as well as in, parts of Europe, right, that they are doing this.
464
01:22:16.280 --> 01:22:22.359
CSIM Presenter: So, yeah, so that's… this is a project, and much of the evidence for these medical deportations
465
01:22:23.970 --> 01:22:29.809
CSIM Presenter: Much of the evidence of these medical deportations were, Or,
466
01:22:30.300 --> 01:22:35.519
CSIM Presenter: I gathered from newspaper reports, right? So these… because
467
01:22:35.750 --> 01:22:38.420
CSIM Presenter: Because hospitals do not have to report.
468
01:22:38.760 --> 01:22:39.980
CSIM Presenter: any of this.
469
01:22:40.100 --> 01:22:45.799
CSIM Presenter: They have no incentive to do so. This is not something they like to advertise.
470
01:22:46.050 --> 01:22:54.019
CSIM Presenter: So instead, it is… sometimes they're just very notorious or pretty traumatic cases that happen that
471
01:22:54.420 --> 01:23:12.269
CSIM Presenter: that is dramatic enough that local media might find it of interest. And then it becomes a news story. So then I tried to track down every news story that I could across the United States. So then I was able to find,
472
01:23:12.560 --> 01:23:30.169
CSIM Presenter: like, I went through hundreds of news articles to track them down. And then I also looked at legal documents, because there are a few medical… I'm sorry, legal cases that were brought… that actually made it to court.
473
01:23:30.250 --> 01:23:39.130
CSIM Presenter: that were challenging, a medical deportation case. And so, I then looked through the, legal documents.
474
01:23:39.130 --> 01:23:56.919
CSIM Presenter: As well as, look through the law reviews and other more, like, legal scholarship on, the ethics and the legality of medical deportation as a way to kind of think through this concept and how it works.
475
01:23:59.000 --> 01:24:07.869
CSIM Presenter: I… I have a… I have a case of a patient with Phoenix who was, she was in a coma and was being deported, but the fact
476
01:24:08.370 --> 01:24:18.600
CSIM Presenter: The family had to hire a lawyer to explain that she was on temporary protected status, and therefore, she was not undocumented, so the
477
01:24:18.710 --> 01:24:29.539
CSIM Presenter: The lawyer had to come to the hospital to explain. The immigration lawyer had to intervene, because she was about to be sent back to Honduras, because,
478
01:24:29.700 --> 01:24:46.770
CSIM Presenter: she was… but she couldn't give consent, and the family was fighting. Yeah, I mean, it's ridiculous, to a point where we found that it's actually not about undocumented. No. Many are, but actually, they're documented, and they're citizens. Children of, immigrant parents.
479
01:24:46.930 --> 01:24:56.109
CSIM Presenter: have also been deported. There's… there are folks with student visas who were forcibly, deported while they're in coma. You know, so these are cases
480
01:24:56.110 --> 01:25:11.049
CSIM Presenter: that have, and so I try to track it as a larger pattern, and not just as singular incidences that are traumatic on its own, but I wanted to show sort of the largest kind of structure, right, of this as part of this system of
481
01:25:11.150 --> 01:25:12.850
CSIM Presenter: the U.S. healthcare system.
482
01:25:14.480 --> 01:25:18.709
CSIM Presenter: But thank you so much, Lisa.
483
01:25:18.860 --> 01:25:27.640
CSIM Presenter: And… And do pay attention to this, publication coming up in July. So, thank you, thank you.